Michigan football is making a significant shift in its punt return strategy following a costly mistake by Semaj Morgan. It seems the Wolverines are turning the page, and the change might be here to stay.
This news broke on November 17, 2025, and comes after a thrilling, albeit messy, victory at Wrigley Field against Northwestern. In a game where Michigan ultimately prevailed with a score of 24-22, the team saw Andrew Marsh replace Morgan in the fourth quarter to handle the final two punts.
When asked if this change would be permanent, Head Coach Sherrone Moore’s response was a simple, yet telling, “probably, yep.” This decision was prompted by a fumble from Morgan during a third-quarter punt return. After cleanly catching the ball and advancing five yards, Morgan was stripped of the ball. This turnover gifted Northwestern prime field position, which they converted into a 35-yard field goal, adding three crucial points to their score.
This fumble was just the latest in a series of setbacks for Morgan this season. His performance in punt returns has been underwhelming, with 13 returns totaling only 30 yards, averaging a mere 2.31 yards per return. His longest return this year was a modest 13 yards, leaving the Michigan special teams unit struggling overall.
Coach Moore acknowledged that the fumble “ate him up,” noting Morgan’s effort to make a play, even breaking tackles, but emphasizing the importance of securing the ball.
The demotion also coincides with a decline in Morgan’s role at wide receiver, marked by dropped passes and a decrease in targets. The receiver from Detroit was only targeted once against Northwestern and hasn’t had a reception since October 18.
Meanwhile, true freshman Andrew Marsh has seen his role expand, both as a receiver and on special teams. Marsh has been the team’s primary kick returner this season and even returned his first punt on Saturday for 12 yards.
Coach Moore also stated that the team will continue to support Morgan, who has faced harsh criticism on social media. Moore highlighted the negativity surrounding young athletes and emphasized the team’s commitment to supporting and caring for their players.
But here’s where it gets controversial… This move raises questions about Morgan’s future with the team and the impact of social media scrutiny on player performance.
What are your thoughts? Do you think this change is the right move for Michigan? Share your opinions in the comments below!